NIOSH Compares Effectiveness of Masks Versus Gaiters

Originally published by: Safety & Health MagazineMarch 31, 2021

The following article was produced and published by the source linked to above, who is solely responsible for its content. SBC Magazine is publishing this story to raise awareness of information publicly available online and does not verify the accuracy of the author’s claims. As a consequence, SBC cannot vouch for the validity of any facts, claims or opinions made in the article.

Faceshields are ineffective at blocking small (0 to 7 microns) airborne particles caused by coughing, results of a recent NIOSH study show.

To gauge the effectiveness of facemasks, neck gaiters and faceshields as a source control and in reducing the spread of COVID-19, researchers used a device that simulates coughs to propel small aerosol particles through the different face coverings, which were placed on a manikin head, lead study author William Lindsley, a biomedical research engineer at NIOSH, said in the March issue of the agency’s eNews newsletter.

“We tested how well face coverings stopped cough aerosols from being expelled into the air,” he added. “We did not test these devices as personal protective equipment to prevent aerosols in the environment from being inhaled by the wearer.”

Results show that a three-ply cotton facemask blocked 51% of aerosol particles. A polyester neck gaiter blocked 47% of aerosol particles when used as a single layer and 60% when folded into a double layer. Faceshields blocked only 2% of the particles.

Lindsley noted the agency is testing other face coverings.

He added: “Our results indicate that any face covering is better than no covering, as also specified by CDC guidelines.”

The study was published online Jan. 7 in the journal Aerosol Science and Technology.


Check out this extra section in each digital issue of SBC Magazine for additional news, perspective, and advertiser content. Learn more and access 2016-2017 archives here.